- Alderson Broaddus (WV)
- Ashland (OH)
- Edinboro (PA)
- Lake Erie (OH)
- Malone (OH)
- Mercyhurst (OH)
- Notre Dame College (OH)
- Ohio Dominican (OH)
- Saginaw Valley State (MI)
- Tiffin (OH)
- University of Charleston (WV)
- Urbana (OH)
- Walsh (OH)
- Wayne State (MI)
- West Liberty (WV)
- Wheeling Jesuit (WV)